Posted by
RabbiHaim on Thursday, March 22, 2007 9:59:15 AM
I have a friend who is a fairly well-known University Teacher, (he hates being called a Professor). In various discussions over the years, he has clearly stated his opinion about the struggle for the State of Israel. His position, distilled down to its essence is that “no land is worth fighting over, or dying for.” To give him the credit due him, it is not really a position, nor is it just about the struggle for Israel; it is a principle, or a principled stance. In his philosophy, it is not appeasement. It may even extend in his mind, at least, to his willingness to forsake his life rather than defend it. Knowing him all these years, though, I don’t believe that it extends to the life of his beloved wife; that he would defend, even at the cost of his own life.
In ordinary circumstances, he is not an “appeaser,” but rather a seeker of peace and truth. He is the tree that bends in the wind and does not break. The prevailing winds about him have indeed caused him to lean a bit to his left, but all things considered, he is a very decent man who believes personally in laissez faire as his guiding light.
I, for my part, respect his intelligence, and education. I also know of some of the magnificent accomplishments he has achieved in his own life and in the lives of those he taught/teaches. In an academic sense he is something of an alchemist; making academic gold out of lead. As a student of students, and as an inspirational figure I hold him high.
But, he has this one fatal flaw; he loves nothing enough to defend it but his wife. He is, indeed, ideologically symbolic of the West.
We in the West, and especially we Americans, only want to get along and continue our [fat and] happy lives. We sit happily in surfeit, complaining loudly when gas prices go up, but continue to consume the gallons. We claim that it is necessary so that we can go to the gym on the other side of town, and then to the upscale restaurant twenty miles from there, to gobble out of season fruits and vegetables as well as the flesh of animals grown hundreds or even thousands of miles away. We watch TV while we lounge or even while we exercise and watch the commercials pitching the panaceas of our culture; food, diet and more luxury.
I am sure that my friend, the Teacher, firmly believes that we can defeat those who wish to destroy our civilization by “inviting them in” and having them succumb to that same lifestyle. I don’t believe that this is possible.
We can start with this thought – they are led by religious beliefs and religious leaders who decry our lifestyle as decadent. They are not attempting to gain our wealth. Though they are poor, their leaders tell them that poor is good. It is almost as if they are fulfilling the Christian idea of “the meek shall inherit the earth.” They wish to take over the world so that we can all live the simple life of the nomadic shepherd, stopping five times a day to pray. They want this so strongly that they are willing to conquer the world an inch at a time, and they are willing to slowly nibble away for as long as it takes, and they mean hundreds of years.
The Jihad is the never-ending struggle to bring the world to Allah. It doesn’t matter if you personally live to see that day on this earth, as long as you are in the struggle actively throughout your life. How do I know this? I know this because they tell us this every day. In Israel they accepted the piece of land called the Gaza Strip. This land had been cultivated and built up over the course of thirty years. Millions of dollars worth of flowers and vegetables were grown there and exported throughout the world. After a long debate, the government of Israel decided to leave the greenhouses, and the infrastructure. The Palestinian Authority [PA] demanded that the government of Israel destroy the houses, as the land was turned over, lest the poor Palestinians fight with each other in envy over the insufficient numbers of houses. What has happened to those greenhouses and to that infrastructure, you might ask. The PA and the citizens of Gaza destroyed them all. The Gaza Strip was returned to its pre-1967 state; it is now a wasteland teeming with people who have no jobs, no industry [other than rocketry], no infrastructure, and most of all no hope.
Speaking of hope, the Israeli people had hoped that this gift would appease the PA and allow the PA to begin building an independent state with an independent economy. The citizens of Sderot and of other Israeli towns are being daily reminded that there is no hope in that direction.
What went wrong? The western-style representative democracy called Israel imputed to the PA its own values. The Western culture of materialism and technology blinded the government of Israel to the knowledge that it should have had about its enemy. The PA, and the people they represent* aren’t interested in land as an end. They are not interested in the possession of that land or in building up a state, an economy, or a nation. Their interest is, to quote Mahmoud Ahmadinijad, “to wipe Israel off the map.**”
Since their intent is destruction of what is and not construction of what isn’t, but could be, they are also not bound by any pressing timetable. They also are philosophically inclined to believe that each small advance is a major victory. In short the PA is fighting a war, while Israel is fighting battle after battle. This may be too subtle of a difference for the Western mind to completely understand, but I will try to explain it:
In historic terms, Hitler was intent on conquering the world. The Allied powers were intent on ending the war. If after the first Nazi incursion, the Third Reich had told the world that it had had enough, and then stood down its armies for a year, the Allies would not have armed. If the Third Reich had repeated that procedure, small incursion after small incursion, it would have been all over and Germany would have won even before the British could mobilize.
Today we are looking at a diffuse global war being waged against Western Civilization by the Moslem world. Make no mistake, “the silent majority of peaceable Moslems” cheers and swells their collective chest with pride each and every time the Jihadists even wound a single person. If they didn’t they would have spoken up a long time ago. They may not want a Sha’ria state in the U.S. because they have had a taste of freedom and techno-bountiful living, but they are still rooting for “the other side.” The West, on the other hand, is culturally and morally confused by the Moslems. The West has a culture of plenty and we know that ninety-nine per cent of the people on this planet would be willing to sacrifice body parts to share in that bounty. We cannot get our heads around the thought that there is a whole philosophy which labels us infidel, or more correctly kafir, and therefore, less worthy of life than dogs or pigs.
In short, then, we can’t blame the appeasers, we must understand them. We must understand that they are doing what they think is right based on their own spiritual philosophical upbringing. We must then, if we wish to survive, educate them to the truth about the enemy who has chosen us. We must remind them that the enemy has chosen us and that we did not chose them.
In the wrong-headedness of the goodhearted left-leaning citizens of the West, they express concern for the members of our Armed Forces whom they feel “should not be put in harm’s way.” What then, is the job of the military, if not to save their sorry posteriors?
WAKE UP and go knock on your neighbors’ doors and wake them up too!!
Or just go learn Arabic.
* The PA and all versions of the “Palestinian” resistance are an outgrowth of the united Arab world’s disdain for the idea of Israel. The financial support of the PA and all its predecessors and cohort to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars per year comes from those countries. The support offered is given with the condition of “millions for weapons, but not a penny for infrastructure, or industry.” The supporting nations include Saudi Arabia and the Persian Gulf States as well as Syria, Egypt, Libya, and of course, the Sudan.
** When quoting Ahmadinijad, one must be careful to understand that there is no way to translate Arabic [or Farsi] into English with any consistency. Whatever you quote back to him, or to most other Arab or Persian spokesperson, will be denied on the grounds that it was mistranslated, and that it couldn’t have meant that in Arabic or Farsi. Be that as it may, the important thing to remember is that the above mentioned [mis]quote is only partial, in that the thought continued to the destruction of the Great Satan and sponsor of Israel; the United States.